Don’t Panic! Managers Don’t Need to be Perfect
Posted by: Emma Trenier & Dr. Sue Harrington
Don’t panic! Employees don’t expect their managers to be incredible at everything.
Capp’s Ideal Manager Survey revealed that there are four strengths that employees consider to be only ‘slightly important’ for their managers:
- Adherence: Sticking to guidelines and best practice templates as required;
- Detail: Ensuring they do not make small errors or mistakes in their work;
- Order: Being very organised with a place for everything;
- Change Agent: Being involved in bringing about change.
Three of these unpopular manager strengths – Adherence, Detail and Order – sit within the ‘Thinking’ strengths family. It is interesting to see this pattern, but why might employees think they are less important than the rest?
- ‘Acceptable’ weaknesses: Over 50,000 people have now taken Realise2, Capp’s flagship strengths assessment tool, and we see that Adherence, Detail and Order are frequently reported as weaknesses – more so than the vast majority of the other 60 strengths measured by Realise2. Perhaps, as a result, employees perceive these as ‘acceptable weaknesses’ in managers?
- The flip side of relating: Alternatively, employees may perceive these three thinking strengths as the flip side of the relating strengths, such as Enabler and Esteem Builder that are rated as most important in a manager. Perhaps the reduced importance of paying attention to details and adhering to guidelines reflects the relatively higher value and weighting placed on managers’ relating strengths?
- Team member roles: Another possibility is that employees do not see these as critical roles for managers – perhaps the roles that require strengths of Adherence, Detail and Order sit with team members rather than managers?
And what of Change Agent? Perhaps employees value stability and consistency from managers, over and above their ability to be constantly bringing about change.
So, as a manager, if these four are not your strengths, and you think they might be tripping you up – even though your employees won’t necessarily be expecting them of you – what can you do?
- Check impact: Check the impact of your lack of fervor in these areas by asking:
- Do I waste my team’s time by constantly changing parameters?
- Do I lower standards by not focusing enough on detail?
- Does my lack of ability to organise my tasks effectively frustrate others?
- Do I cause anxiety within my team by championing and pushing through change too fast, rather than taking my team with me?
- Use your strengths to compensate: Consider how you might use your strengths to help you look at each of these issues afresh. You might also consider seeking complementary strengths from your team to polish up your approach!
- Play to the strengths you do have: Finally, know that your employees value these strengths in their manager less than all others. The best advice you can take is to play to the strengths that you do have to enable you and your team to reach your goals.
Download Capp’s Performance Manager White Paper to find out more about what people want from their managers.